First and foremost, Caerula Mar Club was named one of the best new hotels of 2020 by Conde Nast Traveler, which is no small feat, with the site noting, "Here it's easy to have the best time possible, even when you're doing nothing at all." The resort was lovingly described as, "A crisply smart island hideout in a refreshingly go-slow corner of the Caribbean." Likewise, a second piece by CN Traveler notes the resort is the first of its kind to open on the neglected island in close to 20 years.
Describing it as a "workup of an abandoned mid-century retreat," the publication even suggests the Baeumlers' must-visit location might have put South Andros on the map as the place to visit this year. Likewise, the Robb Report listed Caerula Mar Club as one of its top picks for a Caribbean vacation, positing a stay there is a, "Lesson in relaxation, with outdoor living spaces, meditation paths and hammocks aplenty."
